قرب الإسناد للشيخ عبد الله بن جعفر الحميري
Qarb ul Isnad by Shaikh Humairi
باب ما يجوز من الاشياء
Section on what is permissible among the things (issues)
عبدالله بن الحسن، عن جده علي بن جعفر، عن أخيه موسى ابن جعفر عليه السلام، قال: وسألته عن الغناء، هل يصلح في الفطر والاضحى والفرح؟ قال: " لا بأس به ما لم يعص به
Abdullah b. al Hasan, from his grandfather Ali b. Ja'far, from his brother Musa b. Ja'far(as), (narrator) said: "And I asked him(as) about ghina, is it alright on al fitr, al adha and the occasion of happiness?", Imam(as) said: "No problem with it, unless he disobeys/sins through it."
علي بن جعفر في المسائل: 156 / 219
Masail Ali b. Ja'far, Page 156, Hadith no. 219
وسألته عن الغناء ، أيصلح في الفطر والأضحى والفرح يكون ؟ قال : « لا بأس ما لم يزمر به
And I asked him (as) about the ghina, is it alright on the fitr, adha and the happy occasion? Imam (as) said: "No problem unless he plays/blows (a musical instrument) with it."
بحار الأنوار للمجلسي (1111 هـ) الجزء 10 صفحة 271
Bihar ul Anwar by Majlisi, Volume 10, Page 271
وسألته عن الغناء أيصلح في الفطر والاضحى والفرح ؟ قال : لا بأس ما لم يزمربه
And I asked him (as) about the ghina, is it alright on the fitr, adha and the happy occasion? Imam (as) said: "No problem unless he plays/blows (a musical instrument) with it."
تحقيق عن مسألة الغناء ( الموسيقى ) في نظرة الشيخ الأعظم المحقق الأنصاري ( قدس سره
Research about the issue of ghina (music) in the view of Shaikh al Ansari
ففي صحيح علي بن جعفر عن أخيه ، قال : سألته عن الغناء هل يصلح في الفطر والأضحى والفرح ؟ قال ( عليه السلام ) : ( لا باس به ما لم يعص به
So in the sahih (authentic hadith) of Ali b. Ja'far, from his brother (as), (narrator) said: "And I asked him(as) about ghina, is it alright on al fitr, al adha and the occasion of happiness?", Imam(as) said: "No problem with it, unless he disobeys/sins through it."
جامع المدارك للسيد الخوانساري الجزء 3 صفحة 18
Jami' al Madarik by Syed al Khwansari, Volume 3, Page 18
عن الحميري بسند لم يبعد في الكفاية إلحاقه بالصحاح عن علي بن جعفر عن أخيه عليهما السلام قال: " سألة عن الغناء في الفطر والاضحى والفرح؟ قال: لا بأس ما لم يعص به " وفي كتاب علي بن جعفر عن أخيه " سألته عن الغناء هل يصلح في الفطر والاضحى والفرح؟ قال لا بأس ما لم يزمر به
From al Humairi by a sanad (chain of narration) not far from being graded sahih (authentic) in al Kifayah (Kifayah al ahkam),* from Ali b. Ja'far, from his brother (as), (narrator) said: "And I asked him(as) about ghina, is it alright on al fitr, al adha and the occasion of happiness?", Imam(as) said: "No problem with it, unless he disobeys/sins through it." And in Kitab Masail Ali b. Ja'far from his brother (as), he said: "I asked him (as) about the ghina, is it alright on the fitr, adha and the happy occasion? Imam (as) said: "No problem unless he plays/blows (a musical instrument) with it."
*Translator's note: The line is highlighted in blue due to some technical problems in the text editor, there is nothing special about it.
المكاسب المحرمة للخميني ج1 ص217
Al Makasib al Muhramah (The haram earnings) by Khomeini, Volume 1, Page 217
ويمكن ان يقال باستثناء ايام الفرح منه كعيد الفطر والاضحى وساير الاعياد المذهبية والملية، لصحيحة على بن جعفر عن اخيه موسى عليه السلام قال: سألته عن الغناء هل يصلح في الفطر والاضحى والفرح قال: لا بأس به ما لم يزمر به
And it is possible that it is stated (translator's note: i.e. the impermissibility of ghina) with the exclusion of days of happiness such as Eid al Fitr, al Adha and the rest of the Eids of the madhab and nation, due to the sahih (authentic hadith) of Ali b. Ja'far, from his brother Musa (as), (narrator) said: "I asked him (as) about the ghina, is it alright on the fitr, adha and the happy occasion? Imam (as) said: "No problem unless he plays/blows (a musical instrument) with it."
فقه الصادق للسيد محمد صادق الحسيني الروحاني الجزءالرابع عشر
Fiqh al Sadiq by Ayatullah Sadiq Rohani, Volume 14
الرابع : ماعن قرب الاسناد بسند لم يبعد في الكفاية الحاقة بالصحاح عن علي
بن جعفر عن اخيه عليه السلام قال : سألته عن الغناء في الفطر والاضحى والفرح
قال عليه السلام : لابأس مالم يعص به
The fourth (view): What is narrated from Qarbul Isnad by a sanad (chain of narration) by a sanad (chain of narration) not far from being graded sahih (authentic) in al Kifayah (Kifayah al ahkam)* from Ali b. Ja'far, from his brother (as), (narrator) said: "And I asked him(as) about ghina, is it alright on al fitr, al adha and the occasion of happiness?", Imam(as) said: "No problem with it, unless he disobeys/sins through it."
*Translator's note: The line is highlighted in blue due to some technical problems in the text editor, there is nothing special about it.
No comments:
Post a Comment